OtherNigel was created by bigman20043 as a joke to trick players into thinking he was a 'noob'. He would go onto various games and ask them obvious questions, often ending in him questioning the nicest player as to why they would play on such a "mean game". He started foruming on OT in July of 2015 after his other accounts Creatiom1337 and bigman20043 were terminated.
OtherNigel would often post L2D threads or other 'crapposts' and before long had 1,000 posts. At this point he became more politically opinionated. In early 2016 he had a falling out with one of his earliest OTer friends, ToySackBoyLBP2.